BLUF: The Morris v. Raul case challenges Illinois' suppressor ban by questioning if suppressors are protected under the Second Amendment. Illinois argues suppressors aren't "arms" since they don't fire projectiles. A recent decision on a rifle ban may impact the outcome.
The Morris v. Raul lawsuit challenges a statewide ban in Illinois on suppressors. The plaintiffs argue for the right to own suppressors under the Second Amendment. However, Illinois claims suppressors are not "arms" and should not be protected.
Illinois argues that suppressors don't fire projectiles and are only accessories. They believe this makes them ineligible for Second Amendment protection. The state wants the case dismissed based on this idea.
Recently, a judge delayed the case to await another decision. This decision was on an assault weapon ban in Illinois, known as the Barnett case. The Barnett case ruling found the rifle ban unconstitutional.
The Barnett decision is now being used to support the plaintiffs in Morris v. Raul. They argue that accessories like suppressors increase firearm safety and operability. They also say the Barnett ruling supports their right to own suppressors for self-defense.
The court is considering the Barnett decision as it reviews the suppressor case. The plaintiffs believe the court should not dismiss their case. They argue that a judgment on the pleadings would ignore important constitutional questions.
Though the case is paused, the court may reactivate it soon. The Barnett case is now in the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals, which might affect the suppressor case. The lower court seems interested in moving forward with Morris v. Raul.
The decision could impact future interpretations of firearm-related laws. The outcome of this case might change how suppressors are viewed legally in Illinois and possibly other states.
- Eighth Circuit Court Strikes Down ATF’s Pistol Brace Rule as Arbitrary - December 20, 2024
- Federal Judge Strikes Down ATF’s Force Reset Trigger Restrictions - December 18, 2024
- Supreme Court declines emergency intervention in NYC gun permit case - December 16, 2024
