Judge Roger Benitez ruled that California’s ammo restrictions are invalid. The decision allows Californians to buy ammo online without background checks. The state quickly appealed to the Ninth Circuit for a stay, but the court delayed action.
In California, buying ammo has been tough. Most people need a background check and must buy through a licensed dealer. Judge Benitez has challenged this system. He used a method called “text as informed by history and tradition.” This approach studies the Constitution’s text and how it’s been understood over time. He first made his decision before the Supreme Court’s ruling in Bruen. That case now guides how judges view gun laws.
After the Supreme Court’s Bruen decision, Judge Benitez reviewed the case again. He issued a stronger ruling, sticking to his original view. His decision lifted the background check rules for buying ammo in California. Residents could again buy ammo without these checks and have it shipped to their homes. The change brought quick action from ammo sellers, who started selling directly to Californians.
California fought back, seeking a stay to pause the ruling. Judge Benitez denied a 10-day stay. California then turned to the Ninth Circuit. They wanted an emergency stay, but the court didn’t rush to a decision. The delay allowed California residents to continue buying ammo online. The situation left many unsure about the future of these regulations.
Judge Benitez’s decision received a lot of attention. Supporters see it as a win for gun rights in California. Opponents worry about the impact on public safety. The Ninth Circuit’s delay added to the uncertainty. Many await the court’s next steps and how they might change things again.
The case shows the ongoing struggle over gun laws in the U.S. With decisions like these, the courts continue to shape how states can regulate firearms and ammunition. The outcome of this case could influence future laws and legal battles nationwide.
- Eighth Circuit Court Strikes Down ATF’s Pistol Brace Rule as Arbitrary - December 20, 2024
- Federal Judge Strikes Down ATF’s Force Reset Trigger Restrictions - December 18, 2024
- Supreme Court declines emergency intervention in NYC gun permit case - December 16, 2024
